Kaija Pitt
Direct: 416-371-9447
Office: 416-960-9995
Sotheby’s Canada
1867 Yonge Street, Suite 100
Toronto ON M4S 1Y5 CA

South Hill

North of downtown Toronto, the neighbourhood of South Hillis dominated by a steep escarpment which allows residents here to enjoy stunning panoramic views of the city.Casa Loma, a castle-like mansion built in the early 1900s, is a Toronto landmark and popular tourist destination.


In the late 19th century, South Hill became home to some of Toronto’s wealthiest citizens. Atop the hill, a series of majestic manors were home to some of Toronto’s most influential residents. Senator John Macdonald built Oaklands, which today is part of the private De La Salle College. The Eaton family built Ardwold Estate and James Austin built Spadina House, which is now a museum. Many of the manors that were built on the hill have been demolished or converted to other uses. South Hill remains an upscale neighborhood in Toronto, and even features its own independent (and unofficial) republic, Rathnelly. This midtown community of about 250 homes, banded together in the 1960s to protest various proposed city developments including a roadway that would bisect their neighbourhood. Now the neighbourhood is home for many artists, musicians, writers, journalists and academics.


Defined by Avenue Road, South Hill contains some of the largest houses in Toronto. Mixed in with upscale homes are relatively new condominiums as well as some upscale rental apartment buildings. Families here appreciate the close proximity to some of the most highly regarded public, private and Catholic schools. South Hill is also close to George Brown College, and the Tarragon Theatre – Toronto’s leading venue for independent drama. South Hill is walking distance to the Royal Ontario Art Museum, University of Toronto, Yorkville, Bloor Street and the multi-cultural shops and festivals on St. Clair.


Joggers and those who love going for walks will appreciate the well-lit and family-friendly Nordheimer Ravine, which connects to Toronto’s Beltline Trail. Nearby is Winston Churchill Park, favoured for its running track, playground, and 10 tennis courts. The St. Clair Reservoir is popular with dog walkers.

Forgot password Extend Verify Contact

74B Rathnelly Avenue
Casa Loma Toronto M4V 2M6

$3,999,000
Residential Freehold beds: 3 baths: 5.0

Front Elevation
Photo 1: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 2: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 3: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 4: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 5: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 6: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 7: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 8: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 9: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 10: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 11: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 12: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 13: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 14: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 15: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 16: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 17: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 18: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 19: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 20: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 21: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 22: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 23: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 24: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 25: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 26: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 27: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 28: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 29: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 30: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 31: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 32: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 33: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 34: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 35: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 36: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 37: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 38: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 39: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 40: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 41: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 42: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 43: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 44: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 45: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 46: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 47: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 48: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 49: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Photo 50: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
Status:
Active
Prop. Type:
Residential Freehold
MLS® Num:
C12810478
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
5
Welcome to 74B Rathnelly Ave - a brand-new built 2025, never-lived-in, custom-built luxury home in the prestigious Republic of Rathnelly, one of Toronto's most in-demand neighbourhoods. Steps to Yorkville and close to some of Canada's top private and public schools, this is a truly rare offering with exceptional design, craftsmanship, and high-end finishes throughout.Featuring German-imported Schüco aluminum windows and doors with triple-glazed glass, wide-plank white oak flooring, and a sleek trimless modern design with drywall-groove detailing. Impeccable interior detailing includes custom wall paneling and millwork, a statement mono-beam staircase, glass railings throughout, and upgraded strip lighting/fixtures. Chef's kitchen with custom-painted cabinetry, premium Sub-Zero & Wolf appliances, and natural stone countertops including Super White. Natural stone carries throughout the home (vanities, basement bar, fireplace), highlighted by a dramatic triple-sided marquee fireplace. Spa-inspired bathrooms feature CariMali Italian fixtures and wall-hung Duravit toilets, plus Italian tile and slab finishes with a strong focus on the Italian-slab basement.Enjoy a two-level, double-height heated basement with a large rec room and bar area. The exterior impresses with high-quality linear brick wrapping the sides/rear/walkout, extensive interlock (including interlock driveway), and a standout snow-melt heated system in the driveway, front porch, heated garage area, rear walkout, and even select portions of the backyard for year-round comfort. Entertain on the composite deck and enjoy a large backyard rarely found in the area, complete with composite fencing for a clean, modern finish.Integrated heated garage (extremely rare in the neighbourhood), two furnaces + two A/C systems, high-efficiency spray-foam insulation, smart security/speaker system, central vacuum, and more - a true turnkey statement home in an A+ location.
Property Type:
Residential Freehold
Property Sub Type:
Semi-Detached
Home Style:
2-Storey
Total Approx Floor Area:
2500-3000
Lot Depth:
100'
Lot Frontage:
24'8"
Direction Faces:
West
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
5.0
Water supply:
Municipal
Kitchens:
2
Kitchens in Basement:
1
Bedrooms Above Grade:
3
Kitchens Above Grade:
1
Rooms Above Grade:
6
Rooms Below Grade:
2
Heating type:
Forced Air
Heating Fuel:
Gas
Foundation:
Concrete
Roof:
Metal, Flat
Basement:
Finished with Walk-Out
Fireplace Features:
Natural Gas, Living Room
Fireplace/Stove:
Yes
Garage:
Attached
Garage Spaces:
1.0
Parking Features:
Private
Parking Spaces:
1
Total Parking Spaces:
2.0
Family Room:
Yes
Possession Details:
Immediate
Pool:
None
HST Applicable To Sale Price:
Included In
Taxes:
$0 / 2026
Assessment:
$- / -
Toronto
Toronto C02
Casa Loma
Other, Bar Fridge, ERV/HRV
None
All brand-new, high-end luxury appliances included - featuring a Sub-Zero refrigerator and a Wolf appliance package, including dishwasher, oven, and stove/cooktop.Inclusions: All items and upgrades shown on the feature sheets attached to the listing are included. No rentals - all mechanical systems are owned and included, including the speaker system, central vacuum, boiler, and heated-floor/snow-melt equipment. All custom millwork, mirrors, and built-in wall units are also included.
Brick
Green Property Information Statement:
Yes
Special Designation:
Other
Sewers:
Sewer
Air Conditioning:
Central Air
Central Vacuum:
No
Seller Property Info Statement:
Yes
Date Listed:
Feb 23, 2026
Original Price:
Previous Price:
  • Photo 1: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Front Elevation
  • Photo 2: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Photo 2 of 50
  • Photo 3: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Foyer
  • Photo 4: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Foyer
  • Photo 5: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Dinning
  • Photo 6: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Dinning
  • Photo 7: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Kitchen
  • Photo 8: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Kitchen
  • Photo 9: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Kitchen
  • Photo 10: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Kitchen
  • Photo 11: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Kitchen
  • Photo 12: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Kitchen
  • Photo 13: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Living room
  • Photo 14: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Living room
  • Photo 15: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Living room
  • Photo 16: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Living room
  • Photo 17: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Living room
  • Photo 18: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Bar
  • Photo 19: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Powder Room
  • Photo 20: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Powder Room
  • Photo 21: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Photo 21 of 50
  • Photo 22: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Master Bedroom
  • Photo 23: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Master Bedroom
  • Photo 24: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Master Ensuite
  • Photo 25: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Master Ensuite
  • Photo 26: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Master Ensuite
  • Photo 27: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Master Ensuite
  • Photo 28: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Master Ensuite
  • Photo 29: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Master Walk In Closet
  • Photo 30: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Second floor Laundry
  • Photo 31: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Bedroom 1
  • Photo 32: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Bedroom 1 Ensuite
  • Photo 33: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Bedroom 2
  • Photo 34: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Bedroom 2
  • Photo 35: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Bedroom 2 Ensuite
  • Photo 36: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Bedroom 2 Ensuite
  • Photo 37: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Mono Staircase
  • Photo 38: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Living room
  • Photo 39: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Living room
  • Photo 40: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Living room
  • Photo 41: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Double Height Basement
  • Photo 42: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Double Height Basement, BAR
  • Photo 43: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Double Height Basement/BAR
  • Photo 44: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Basement Bathroom
  • Photo 45: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Double Height Basement, BAR
  • Photo 46: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Double Height Basement, BAR
  • Photo 47: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Back Walk out
  • Photo 48: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    dog Wash/ Laundry
  • Photo 49: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Front Elevation
  • Photo 50: 74B Rathnelly Avenue in Toronto: Casa Loma House for sale (Toronto C02)  : MLS®# C12810478
    Back Elevation
Listed by RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
Data was last updated March 3, 2026 at 06:15 AM (UTC)
Area Statistics
Listings on market:
31
Avg list price:
$2,795,000
Min list price:
$799,000
Max list price:
$8,580,000
Avg days on market:
29
Min days on market:
1
Max days on market:
180
These statistics are generated based on the current listing's property type and located in Toronto C02. Average values are derived using median calculations. This data is not produced by the MLS® system.
This website may only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate of the type being offered via the website. The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the MLS® Reciprocity program of the PropTx MLS®. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate.